A single bench of Justice Uday Kumar of the Calcutta High Court held that 'public view' under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 'transcends physical space into the digital domain'.
The case, Sri Sayan Mondal v. State of West Bengal (CRR 2992 of 2023), concerned casteist abuse of a Scheduled Caste complainant on Facebook.
The court set aside the Special Court's acceptance of a police 'no clue' final report and ordered further investigation by specialised cyber-forensic personnel, with a report due in three months.
The ruling follows the Supreme Court's 20 August 2026 decision in Ramkrishna Chauhan v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which applied the 'public view' test strictly to a physical space.
Enacted in 1989 and in force from 30 January 1990 to give teeth to Article 17. Section 3(1)(r) penalises intentionally insulting or intimidating an SC/ST member with intent to humiliate, and Section 3(1)(s) penalises abusing such a member by caste name - both 'in any place within public view'.
Recast Section 3 and expanded the list of offences; the old Section 3(1)(x) on caste insult became the present clauses (r) and (s). In force from 26 January 2016.
Section 18 bars anticipatory bail. Section 18A, inserted in 2018 after the Subhash Kashinath Mahajan ruling, says no preliminary enquiry is needed before an FIR and no approval before arrest.
Abolishes untouchability and makes enforcing any disability arising from it an offence punishable by law.
Permits further investigation after a final report has been filed - the route the High Court used here.
The test is whether members of the public could see or hear the insult, not who owns the spot. A private lawn visible from the road qualifies; a closed room with no outsider present does not. The High Court applied this to posts visible online.
Simple Analogy: An insult shouted from a balcony counts; the same words whispered behind a shut door do not.
Swaran Singh v. State: Supreme Court separates 'public place' from 'place within public view'; even a private spot counts if the public can witness the act.
Hitesh Verma v. State of Uttarakhand (three-judge bench): an utterance within four walls, with no member of the public present, is not within public view.
Police file a 'no clue' final report in the Behala Facebook-abuse case.
Special Court, Alipore, rejects the complainant's protest petition.
Ramkrishna Chauhan v. State of Uttar Pradesh (Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta): an incident inside school premises does not by itself satisfy public view; proceedings quashed.
Calcutta High Court extends public view to the digital domain and orders a cyber-forensic investigation.
Established in 1862, the oldest High Court in India; its jurisdiction covers West Bengal and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. A single-judge ruling binds courts within that jurisdiction and is persuasive elsewhere.
Courts of Session designated, or Exclusive Special Courts established, by the State Government with the concurrence of the Chief Justice of the High Court to try offences under the Act speedily.
GS Paper 2 > Mechanisms and laws for protection of vulnerable sections; Judiciary
General Awareness > Polity > Fundamental Rights (Article 17) and social legislation
Which of the following was the first High Court established in India?
Answer: Calcutta High Court
Which one of the following categories of Fundamental Rights incorporates protection against untouchability as a form of discrimination?
Answer: Right to Equality
Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with the "Abolition of Untouchability"?
Answer: Article 17
Which article of the Indian Constitution deals with the 'Abolition of Untouchability'?
Answer: Article 17
Any place, public or private, where members of the public can see or hear the act; the Calcutta High Court has read it to include social media.
A complainant's objection filed before the court when the police submit a closure or final report.
Fresh investigative steps after a final report, allowed by Section 173(8) CrPC, as distinct from a re-investigation from scratch.