On 6 October 2026 a seven-judge Constitution Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant disposed of the reference in N. Ravi v. Speaker, Legislative Assembly, Chennai as infructuous.
The case began in 2003, when the Tamil Nadu Assembly sentenced five journalists of The Hindu to 15 days' simple imprisonment for breach of privilege.
The Assembly withdrew that resolution on 30 July 2004, so nothing was left to decide on the facts.
The questions of law on Articles 194(3), 19(1)(a) and 21 were left open for an appropriate future case, so the conflict between the 1958 Searchlight ruling and the 1964 Keshav Singh opinion stays unresolved.
Privileges of a state legislature, its members and committees: such as the legislature defines by law, and until so defined, those existing immediately before the 44th Amendment (1978) came into force. They have never been codified.
The identical provision for the two Houses of Parliament. Parliament too has never enacted a law defining its privileges.
Removed the original reference to the privileges of the British House of Commons from Articles 105(3) and 194(3) and tied them instead to the position on the date the amendment came into force.
Free speech, which includes press freedom, and personal liberty. The petitioners argued that jailing journalists for breach of privilege must satisfy both.
| Point | Pandit M.S.M. Sharma v. Sri Krishna Sinha (1958) | Special Reference No. 1 of 1964 (Keshav Singh) |
|---|---|---|
| Popular name | Searchlight case | Keshav Singh case |
| Facts | Bihar Assembly acted against the editor of Searchlight for publishing expunged proceedings | UP Assembly jailed a citizen over a pamphlet, then ordered the two High Court judges who granted him bail brought before the House |
| Bench | 5 judges, 4:1 majority | 7 judges, on a Presidential reference under Article 143 |
| Key holding | Article 19(1)(a), a general provision, must yield to privilege under Article 194(3) | Courts may examine whether a claimed privilege exists, and Article 21 applies when a legislature commits a person |
Searchlight case: privilege prevails over Article 19(1)(a)
Keshav Singh opinion by seven judges under Article 143
Tamil Nadu Assembly sentences five journalists of The Hindu to 15 days' simple imprisonment
Supreme Court stays the arrest warrants and refers the constitutional questions to a larger bench
Assembly unanimously withdraws the 2003 resolution
Sita Soren v. Union of India: seven judges hold that bribery is not protected by legislative privilege, overruling P.V. Narasimha Rao (1998)
Seven-judge bench disposes of the N. Ravi reference as infructuous
Under Article 145(3), a bench of at least five judges decides substantial questions of constitutional interpretation. Seven judges sat here because the two precedents to be reconciled included a seven-judge opinion.
A committee of each House or legislature. It examines breach-of-privilege complaints referred by the Presiding Officer and recommends action.
GS Paper II > Parliament and State Legislatures > Powers, privileges and issues arising
GS Paper II > Fundamental Rights > Article 19 and press freedom
Who/Which of the following is the custodian of the Constitution of India?
Answer: The Supreme Court of India
We adopted parliamentary democracy based on the British model, but how does our model differ from that model? 1. As regards legislation, the British Parliament is supreme or sovereign but in India, the power of the Parliament to legislate is limited. 2. In India, matters related to the constitutionality of the Amendment of an Act of the Parliament are referred to the Constitution Bench by the Supreme Court. Select the correct answer using the code given below.
Answer: Both 1 and 2
Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with the "Protection of interests of minorities"?
Answer: Article 29
The "Right to Freedom of Religion" is guaranteed under which Articles?
Answer: Articles 25-28
Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with the "Abolition of Untouchability"?
Answer: Article 17
Special rights and immunities of a House, its members and committees, meant to protect the House's independent functioning
A case that no longer serves a purpose because the event behind it has ceased to exist
The President seeking the Supreme Court's advisory opinion, as in the Keshav Singh case (1964)