In an office memorandum of 31 August 2026 the Ministry of Tribal Affairs said the Forest Rights Act, 2006 and its Rules have no provision for Gram Sabha consent for Stage-II forest clearance, and that the matter is outside its purview.
It followed the 31st Report of the Committee on Public Undertakings, presented on 6 August 2026, which found that forest clearance for NHPC's under-construction projects took 106 months on average and took up a proposal for a 70-75% super-majority of Gram Sabhas.
The Act's text is silent on consent for diversion. The requirement came from a Ministry of Environment circular of 3 August 2009, was upheld in spirit by the Supreme Court in the Niyamgiri case (2013) and was written into the forest rules in 2014 and 2017.
The Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022 moved the step to the State Government after the Centre's final approval, so no central ministry now answers for whether consent was taken.
By 30 June 2026, 54.02 lakh forest rights claims had been filed and 25.42 lakh titles distributed; 10.46 lakh claims were pending and community claims were about 4% of the total.
The choice before the government is whether consent stays with every affected Gram Sabha, moves to a threshold, or is written into statute with a time limit.
The Ministry is right on the text and incomplete on the law. No section of the Forest Rights Act says a Gram Sabha must consent before forest land is diverted. But Section 4(5) bars eviction until recognition of rights is complete, Section 5 empowers the Gram Sabha to protect forests, wildlife and its cultural heritage, and Section 3(1)(i) gives it the right to manage community forest resources. In Orissa Mining Corporation (2013) the Supreme Court read these with Articles 25 and 26 and PESA, and left the decision on Niyamgiri to the Gram Sabhas. Consent is thus a consequence of vested rights, though its procedure sits in rules made under the 1980 Act.
The consent step has moved three times. The 2009 circular placed it with the proposal, the 2017 rules made the District Collector answerable for it before in-principle approval, and the 2022 Rules shifted it to the State Government after the Centre's final approval. The Environment Ministry says the Act must still be complied with before land is handed over. The Tribal Affairs Ministry, the Act's nodal agency under Section 11, now says the matter is outside its purview. A Gram Sabha that disputes a consent record therefore has no central ministry to approach. The Hasdeo inquiry, which found a mining proposal added after meetings had ended, shows why an owner is needed.
NHPC told the committee that forest clearance for its under-construction projects took 106 months on average, and the committee called 100% Gram Sabha consent the single most critical bottleneck. Delay adds interest during construction and pushes up tariffs, and hydropower is valued for balancing solar and wind. Against this, hydel projects took 13,136 hectares of the 1.73 lakh hectares of forest approved for diversion between 2014-15 and 2023-24, while mining took 58,282 hectares. Forest land also carries an economy of its own: minor forest produce, grazing and water on which forest-dwelling households depend. The task is to price delay without treating that economy as free land.
The Act was passed to undo what its preamble calls a historic injustice, and consent is the point at which that promise meets a project. By 30 June 2026, 54.02 lakh claims had been filed and 25.42 lakh titles issued, but 10.46 lakh were pending and 18.13 lakh had been rejected. Community claims were about 4% of the total. Where rights are unrecorded, a community cannot show what it stands to lose. The stakes are highest for Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups such as the Dongria Kondh of Niyamgiri and the Shompen of Great Nicobar, for whom the forest is livelihood, faith and identity together.
Consent and conservation are often treated as rivals, and the record is mixed. A 2008 petition by Wildlife First and other groups argues that the Act leads to deforestation and encroachment; the Supreme Court's order of 13 February 2019 to evict rejected claimants, stayed on 28 February 2019, came in that case. Yet Section 5 gives the Gram Sabha a duty to protect wildlife, biodiversity and catchments, and forest clearance is the main lawful route by which forest is lost: 1,73,396.87 hectares were approved for non-forest use in ten years. Supporters of consent argue that a Gram Sabha's refusal is sometimes the last check a forest gets.
Section 4(5) bars removal of a forest dweller until recognition of rights is complete, and Section 5 empowers the Gram Sabha to stop activity that harms forests, wildlife or its cultural heritage. In Orissa Mining Corporation (2013) the Supreme Court relied on these provisions to leave the Niyamgiri decision to the Gram Sabhas. Taking the land without consent would leave those rights without a remedy.
A Community Forest Resource is the customary forest of one village. If seven of ten villages agree, as at Teesta-IV in North Sikkim, the other three still lose their own forest. A 70-75% threshold counted across villages lets those who keep their land decide for those who lose it, which differs from a majority decision taken inside a single Gram Sabha.
In November 2024 the Chhattisgarh State Scheduled Tribes Commission found that Gram Sabha consent for the 1,252-hectare Parsa coal block in Hasdeo Arand rested on forged records and recommended cancelling the clearance. In Great Nicobar the Tribal Council withdrew its no-objection certificate on 22 November 2022, saying it had not been told the full facts. A weaker rule would be harder still to police.
Between 2008-09 and 2022-23, the period in which the 2009 circular and the later rules applied, 17,301 projects covering 3,05,945.38 hectares of forest were approved. Niyamgiri remains the best-known refusal. Critics of the committee's finding note that the consent requirement applies to all projects, yet most have been cleared.
The Tribal Affairs Ministry's memorandum of 31 August 2026 states that the Act and its Rules contain no provision for Gram Sabha consent for Stage-II clearance. The requirement began as an executive circular in 2009 and has been altered by later circulars and rules. A veto of this weight, on this view, should be created and limited by Parliament and not by executive instruction.
The Committee on Public Undertakings recorded an average of 106 months for forest clearance of NHPC's under-construction projects and described the 520 MW Teesta-IV project as indefinitely stalled although seven of ten gram panchayat units had consented. Long delays raise project cost and tariffs and slow the hydropower capacity needed to balance solar and wind.
Indian law already uses thresholds. The Land Acquisition Act of 2013 requires the consent of 80% of affected families for private projects and 70% for public-private partnerships. A circular of 5 February 2013 exempted linear projects from Gram Sabha consent, and the T.S.R. Subramanian High Level Committee (2014) recommended dispensing with it for such projects.
NHPC placed before the committee benchmarks from Brazil, Australia and New Zealand. Australia's Native Title Act, 1993 gives native title holders a right to negotiate, not a right to stop a project. In Haida Nation (2004) the Supreme Court of Canada held that the duty to consult does not give Aboriginal groups a veto while a claim is unproven.
Right to protect and manage community forest resources; no eviction until recognition of rights is complete; Gram Sabha's power to protect forest, wildlife and cultural heritage; Gram Sabha initiates determination of rights; Ministry of Tribal Affairs is the nodal agency.
The two places where the Act itself asks for the Gram Sabha's say: its recommendation for small government facilities (under 1 hectare, not more than 75 trees per hectare), and its free informed consent in writing before resettlement from a critical wildlife habitat.
Section 2 requires the Centre's prior approval before forest land is used for a non-forest purpose. Approval is given in two stages; the consent step sits in circulars and rules made under this Act.
Notified on 28 June 2022. The Centre gives in-principle and final approval without a consent step; the State Government is to ensure settlement of forest rights before it issues the diversion order.
In Scheduled Areas the Gram Sabha or the Panchayat at the appropriate level must be consulted before land is acquired for a development project and before resettlement.
Provide for the administration of Scheduled Areas, with a Tribes Advisory Council and the Governor's power to modify the application of laws.
Life and livelihood, freedom of religion and the protection of distinct culture. The Supreme Court relied on Articles 25 and 26 in the Niyamgiri case to protect the Dongria Kondh's worship of Niyam Raja.
The Union and every State shall consult the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes on all major policy matters affecting Scheduled Tribes. The Commission invoked the want of consultation against the 2022 Rules.
Consent of 80% of affected families for private projects and 70% for public-private partnerships; prior consent of the Gram Sabha for acquisition in Scheduled Areas.
| Instrument | Position on Gram Sabha consent | Who answers for it |
|---|---|---|
| MoEF circular, 3 August 2009 | A diversion proposal must carry Gram Sabha resolutions certifying that recognition of rights is complete and that the Gram Sabha consents | State Government, with the proposal |
| MoEF circular, 5 February 2013 | Linear projects (roads, canals, pipelines, transmission lines) exempt, unless rights of primitive tribal groups are affected | Environment Ministry |
| Forest (Conservation) Rules as amended in 2014 and 2017 | Recognition of rights and consent of each Gram Sabha before in-principle approval | District Collector |
| Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022 | No consent step before the Centre's approval; rights to be settled before the diversion order | State Government |
| Tribal Affairs Ministry memorandum, 31 August 2026 | The Act and its Rules have no provision for Gram Sabha consent for Stage-II clearance | Not in the Ministry's purview |
Forest (Conservation) Act requires the Centre's prior approval for non-forest use of forest land
PESA requires consultation with the Gram Sabha or Panchayat before land acquisition in Scheduled Areas
Forest Rights Act, 2006 comes into force
Environment Ministry circular asks for Gram Sabha consent with every diversion proposal
N.C. Saxena committee finds the Niyamgiri mining proposal in violation of the Act
Linear projects exempted from Gram Sabha consent
Supreme Court, in Orissa Mining Corporation, leaves the Niyamgiri decision to the Gram Sabhas
All 12 Gram Sabhas reject bauxite mining; final clearance refused in January 2014
Virginius Xaxa Committee backs mandatory Gram Sabha consent for land acquisition; T.S.R. Subramanian Committee recommends dispensing with it for linear projects
Supreme Court orders eviction of rejected claimants in the Wildlife First case, then stays its order
Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022 leave settlement of rights to the State after the Centre's final approval
Chhattisgarh State Scheduled Tribes Commission finds forged consent records for the Parsa coal block
Committee on Public Undertakings presents its 31st Report, on NHPC
Tribal Affairs Ministry says Gram Sabha consent for forest clearance is outside its purview
Approval to divert forest land under the 1980 Act comes in two steps. Stage-I, or in-principle approval, is the Centre's decision that the land may be diverted, subject to conditions such as providing land for compensatory afforestation and paying the net present value of the forest. Stage-II, or final approval, is given after the user agency reports compliance with those conditions. The State Government then issues the order handing over the land. The dispute is about where the Gram Sabha fits. Under the 2017 rules its consent came before Stage-I, so a refusal could shape the decision. Under the 2022 Rules the Centre can complete both stages first, and the settlement of forest rights is left to the State before it issues the final order. A consent sought after money has been paid and approval granted is harder to refuse.
Simple Analogy: It is the difference between asking the residents before the building plan is sanctioned and asking them after the builder has paid the fees and received the sanction.
The 2008 challenge to the Forest Rights Act is still pending in the Supreme Court. Its 2019 eviction order, since stayed, showed how many forest dwellers remain without recognised rights when projects or evictions arrive.
PESA gives Gram Sabhas in Scheduled Areas a right to be consulted on land acquisition. The Forest Rights Act applies to forest land everywhere, inside and outside Scheduled Areas.
Its 70% and 80% family-consent thresholds are the nearest Indian precedent for a super-majority, but they count families inside the project area and not villages.
The Tribal Council of Little and Great Nicobar withdrew its no-objection certificate in November 2022, and tribal leaders say their forest rights have not been recognised.
Hydropower and pumped storage are needed to balance solar and wind, and much of the remaining potential lies in the Himalayan and North-Eastern States, where forest cover and tribal populations are high.
Orissa Mining Corporation sought forest land in the Niyamgiri hills of Rayagada and Kalahandi to mine bauxite for Vedanta's Lanjigarh refinery. The hills are home to the Dongria Kondh, a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group that worships the hilltop as Niyam Raja.
A committee headed by N.C. Saxena reported in August 2010 that the proposal violated the Forest Rights Act. On 18 April 2013 the Supreme Court directed that the Gram Sabhas decide whether mining would affect their religious and cultural rights.
All 12 Gram Sabhas rejected the proposal in July-August 2013, and the Environment Ministry refused final clearance in January 2014. The refinery continued to operate.
Consent works when it is taken by the Gram Sabha itself, under judicial supervision, and the government accepts the answer.
Forest clearance for the 1,252-hectare Parsa coal block in Surguja and Surajpur districts rested on Gram Sabha resolutions from Salhi, Hariharpur and Fatehpur villages. In 2021, 41 residents complained that the resolutions were forged.
The Chhattisgarh State Scheduled Tribes Commission inquired into the complaint. It found mismatches in the attendance records and evidence that the mining proposal had been added after the Gram Sabha meetings had concluded.
In November 2024 the Commission recommended that the forest clearance be cancelled and directed the district administration to convene the three Gram Sabhas afresh.
A consent rule is only as strong as its record. Without independent verification and an authority that owns the process, consent can be produced without being given.
The Juukan Gorge rock shelters in Western Australia's Pilbara held evidence of 46,000 years of human occupation and were sacred to the Puutu Kunti Kurrama and Pinikura people. Rio Tinto held ministerial consent, given in 2013 under Section 18 of the state's Aboriginal Heritage Act, to mine the area.
On 24 May 2020 the company blasted the shelters to expand an iron ore mine. The act was lawful; the traditional owners had no legal power to refuse.
A parliamentary inquiry tabled its final report, 'A Way Forward', on 18 October 2021. It recommended new national heritage legislation built on free, prior and informed consent.
A system that offers consultation without the right to refuse can permit an irreversible loss, and the country cited as a benchmark for lighter consent is itself moving the other way.
The Tribal Affairs Ministry has read the statute accurately and has left the question unanswered. Consent for forest diversion was built by circular, upheld by the Supreme Court in Niyamgiri and then moved from the Centre to the District Collector to the State. The result is a requirement that everyone acknowledges and no ministry owns, which serves neither the forest dweller nor the developer who waits nine years. The durable answer is legislative: a consent procedure written into law, placed before approval and not after it, with a time limit that gives projects certainty and a record that gives Gram Sabhas a remedy.
“The Forest Rights Act, 2006 does not expressly require Gram Sabha consent for diversion of forest land, yet such consent has been treated as mandatory. Examine the legal basis of the requirement and the recent debate on diluting it. (250 words)”
“'Development projects and the rights of forest dwellers need not be in conflict if consent is designed well.' Discuss with reference to the Niyamgiri judgment and the Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022. (250 words)”
“Compare the role of the Gram Sabha under PESA, 1996, the Forest Rights Act, 2006 and the Land Acquisition Act, 2013. (150 words)”
GS2 > Government policies and interventions; welfare of vulnerable sections; GS3 > Conservation and environmental impact assessment
Polity and Environment > Forest Rights Act, PESA, Forest (Conservation) Act
Tribal welfare; Scheduled Areas; forest governance
Under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006, who shall be the authority to initiate the process for determining the nature and extent of individual or community forest rights or both?
At the national level, which ministry is the nodal agency to ensure effective implementation of the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006?
Consider the following statements: 1. The definition of "Critical Wildlife Habitat" is incorporated in the Forest Rights Act, 2006. 2. For the first time in India, Baigas have been given Habitat Rights. 3. Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change officially decides and declares Habitat Rights for Primitive and Vulnerable Tribal Groups in any part of India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: 1 and 2 only
UPSC Prelims: asked directly in 2013 and 2021. PESA, Scheduled Areas and forest governance recur in GS2 and GS3 Mains.
The village assembly of all adult members, which initiates the determination of forest rights and is empowered to protect the forest.
Customary common forest land within a village's traditional boundaries, which the community has a right to protect and manage under Section 3(1)(i).
The Centre's final approval for diverting forest land, given after the conditions of in-principle (Stage-I) approval are met.
Consent given without coercion, before a project is approved and with full information; the standard in the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.
Roads, canals, pipelines and transmission lines, which were exempted from Gram Sabha consent by a circular of 5 February 2013.
The Forest Rights Act, 2006 does not expressly require Gram Sabha consent for diversion of forest land, yet such consent has been treated as mandatory. Examine the legal basis of this requirement and critically analyse the proposal to replace it with a super-majority threshold. (250 words)
'Rights that no authority is responsible for enforcing are rights only on paper.' Discuss in the context of the division of responsibility between the Ministry of Tribal Affairs and the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change over forest rights and forest clearance. (150 words)