Three states now have a Uniform Civil Code law. Uttarakhand's has been in force since 27 January 2025, and the President assented to Gujarat's on 17 September 2026 and to Assam's on 29 September 2026.
Madhya Pradesh's Assembly passed its Bill on 21 July 2026 and awaits assent. Rajasthan and Maharashtra have drafting committees, and West Bengal announced a roadmap in June 2026.
States can legislate because family law is in the Concurrent List, but a state code that conflicts with central law needs the President's assent under Article 254(2).
Every state code exempts Scheduled Tribes and each sets its own offences and penalties, so Article 44's promise of one code 'throughout the territory of India' is being met in pieces.
The codes ban polygamy, give sons and daughters equal inheritance and make registration compulsory, but compulsory registration of live-in couples faces a privacy challenge.
The 21st Law Commission (2018) preferred reforming each personal law. The 23rd Law Commission, whose term runs to August 2027, has the question before it again.
Marriage, divorce, adoption and succession sit in Entry 5 of the Concurrent List, so a state legislature is competent to pass a family code. Because such a code collides with central statutes like the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and the Indian Succession Act, 1925, it survives only with the President's assent under Article 254(2), and Parliament can still override it later. Article 44 speaks of one code 'throughout the territory of India', yet 'the State' in Part IV includes state legislatures by virtue of Articles 12 and 36. The harder tests lie ahead: Article 14 challenges to the tribal exemption, and Article 21 challenges to compulsory live-in registration after K.S. Puttaswamy (2017).
The code is advancing through states governed by one party rather than through Parliament. Uttarakhand, Gujarat, Assam and Madhya Pradesh have passed codes, and Rajasthan, Maharashtra and West Bengal are drafting. For the Centre, the state route avoids a national Bill that would have to carry Nagaland, Mizoram and the Sixth Schedule areas, where Articles 371A and 371G and the autonomous councils protect customary law. The cost is that a Directive addressed to the whole country is being met along party lines. Madhya Pradesh's Bill passed amid an Opposition protest, and a change of government in any state could reopen family law that citizens had treated as settled.
The strongest case for the codes is gender justice. They ban polygamy, require divorce through a court, give sons and daughters equal shares and make registration of marriage compulsory, which gives a wife documentary proof of her status. Yet the practices they target are rare. NFHS-5 put polygynous marriages at 1.4%, with Christians at 2.1%, Muslims at 1.9% and Hindus at 1.3%. The highest rate, 2.4%, was among Scheduled Tribes, the one group every state code exempts. Critics therefore note that tribal women are left outside the equal-inheritance guarantee, while communities that are covered see the reform as aimed at them.
Implementation rests on the registrar more than the court. Uttarakhand moved registration online and issues certificates in about five days against a 15-day limit; daily registrations rose from about 67 to nearly 1,400. The live-in provision has worked differently. Only 68 relationships were registered in the same period, the clause is under challenge in the Uttarakhand High Court, and the state amended the Act by ordinance on 27 January 2026. Each state also writes its own rules and penalties, so a couple that moves across a state border changes its family law. No mechanism yet reconciles the state codes with one another.
Two values the Constitution prizes are in tension. Equality requires that a woman's rights in marriage and inheritance should not depend on the faith she was born into. Autonomy and freedom of conscience require that the state should not police intimate choices or remake a community's customs without its consent. Compulsory registration of live-in couples, with jail for default and notice to parents when a partner is under 21, may protect some women but exposes inter-faith and inter-caste couples to pressure. Ambedkar's own answer in 1948 was to begin with a voluntary code. The test of fairness is whether reform is done with communities or to them.
Entry 5 of the Concurrent List covers marriage, divorce, adoption and succession, and Article 44 is addressed to 'the State', which includes state legislatures. Gujarat's and Assam's Bills were reserved for the President and received assent in September 2026 under Article 254(2), the route the Constitution itself provides for a state law that departs from a central law.
The codes prohibit polygamy, require judicial divorce and give daughters and sons equal inheritance. Compulsory registration creates proof of marriage, which matters in maintenance and succession disputes. In Uttarakhand, registrations rose from about 67 a day under the earlier law to nearly 1,400 a day, with 4,74,447 marriages registered by 19 January 2026.
In Pannalal Bansilal Pitti (1996) the Supreme Court said a uniform law enacted in one go may be counter-productive and favoured step-by-step change. State codes let the country test drafting choices, see what courts strike down and correct errors, as Uttarakhand did by ordinance in January 2026, before Parliament attempts a national law.
Goa has followed the Portuguese Civil Code of 1867 across communities for over 150 years. In Jose Paulo Coutinho v. Maria Luiza Valentina Pereira (2019) the Supreme Court called it a shining example of a state with a uniform civil code applicable to all, while noting that it protects certain limited rights.
Article 44 envisages one code throughout India. Instead each state sets its own offences and penalties: Assam's law provides up to seven years' imprisonment for polygamy, while Madhya Pradesh's Bill provides up to five years for a married person who enters a live-in relationship. A family's rights now change at the state border, the outcome a uniform code was meant to end.
Every state code leaves out Scheduled Tribes, who are 21.1% of Madhya Pradesh's population, 14.8% of Gujarat's and 12.4% of Assam's (Census 2011). If equality between men and women is the purpose, excluding the group with the highest recorded polygyny rate (2.4% in NFHS-5) is hard to defend, and it invites an Article 14 challenge from those who are covered.
Live-in couples in Uttarakhand and Gujarat must register or face up to three months in jail, a fine of up to Rs 10,000, or both. After K.S. Puttaswamy (2017), such an intrusion must be necessary and proportionate. Only 68 live-in relationships were registered in Uttarakhand in nearly a year, which suggests the rule deters disclosure more than it protects partners.
Madhya Pradesh's Assembly passed its Bill by voice vote on 21 July 2026, the day after it was tabled, amid an Opposition protest. One retired judge has chaired the drafting panels of several states. In September 2026 Justice R.C. Chavan quit Maharashtra's panel, objecting to a yes/no public questionnaire. The 21st Law Commission had advised reforming each personal law instead.
Directs the State to endeavour to secure a uniform civil code. 'The State' has the same meaning as in Part III (Article 36), so it includes state legislatures. Article 37 makes the Directive non-justiciable but fundamental in governance.
Marriage and divorce, infants and minors, adoption, wills, intestacy and succession, joint family and partition. Both Parliament and state legislatures can legislate.
A state law on a Concurrent subject that is repugnant to an earlier central law prevails in that state if it was reserved for the President and received assent. The proviso lets Parliament later amend, vary or repeal it.
The Governor may reserve a Bill for the President's consideration; the President may assent or withhold assent.
Equality, non-discrimination on grounds of sex and religion, and personal liberty including privacy. These are the grounds on which both personal laws and the new codes are tested.
Freedom of religion, of religious denominations and of cultural minorities. Article 25(2) allows the State to regulate secular activity associated with religious practice and to legislate for social reform.
Protect Naga and Mizo customary law and practice from parliamentary law unless the state Assembly agrees, and let autonomous district councils legislate on marriage, divorce, inheritance and social customs.
An optional civil law of marriage open to any two persons regardless of religion. It is the closest thing to the voluntary code Ambedkar described.
| Feature | Uttarakhand | Gujarat | Assam | Madhya Pradesh |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assembly passed | 7 February 2024 | 24 March 2026 | 27 May 2026 | 21 July 2026 |
| President's assent | March 2024 | 17 September 2026 | 29 September 2026 | Awaited |
| Status | In force since 27 January 2025 | Notified as Act No. 15 of 2026; commencement date to be notified | Assented; rules to be notified | Bill passed; not yet law |
| Scheduled Tribes | Exempt | Exempt | Exempt | Exempt, along with PVTGs |
| Live-in relationships | Registration compulsory | Registration within 30 days | Registration required | Registration within one month |
| Polygamy | Banned | Banned | Banned; up to 7 years' imprisonment | Banned |
Portuguese Civil Code, which still governs family law in Goa
Constituent Assembly debates and adopts draft Article 35, later Article 44
Special Marriage Act, then four statutes codifying Hindu family law
Shah Bano: the Supreme Court regrets that Article 44 has remained a dead letter
Sarla Mudgal urges a common code; Pannalal Bansilal Pitti cautions against enacting it in one go
21st Law Commission: a UCC is 'neither necessary nor desirable at this stage'
22nd Law Commission invites public views afresh
Uttarakhand Assembly passes the first state UCC
Uttarakhand's code comes into force
Gujarat Assembly passes its UCC Bill
Assam Assembly passes its UCC Bill
Madhya Pradesh Assembly passes its UCC Bill
President assents to the Gujarat and Assam Bills
Gujarat notifies its code as Act No. 15 of 2026
When a state law and a central law on the same Concurrent List subject cannot both be obeyed, they are repugnant. The general rule in Article 254(1) is that the central law prevails and the state law is void to the extent of the conflict. Article 254(2) carves out one exception: if the state law was reserved for the President's consideration and received assent, it prevails in that state. Parliament keeps the last word, because the proviso lets it pass a later law that amends or repeals the state law. This is why each state UCC Bill went to the President and not only to the Governor.
Simple Analogy: A housing society has common rules for every flat. One flat-owner may follow a different rule only with the society chairman's written permission, and the society can withdraw that permission by changing the common rules later.
Goa was under Portuguese rule until 1961 and followed the Portuguese Civil Code of 1867. Parliament let that law continue after Goa joined India.
The code requires civil registration of marriage, treats property acquired by spouses as jointly owned by default and limits a parent's power to disinherit children. It has exceptions: limited customary allowances for Hindus and church marriages for Catholics.
A common code has governed all communities in Goa for over 150 years. The Supreme Court called it a shining example in Jose Paulo Coutinho (2019), while recording that it protects certain limited rights.
A common code can be accepted when it has grown with the society it governs, and even the most cited model is not fully uniform.
Uttarakhand enforced the first state UCC on 27 January 2025, with compulsory registration of marriages and live-in relationships through an online portal.
Marriage registration was moved online with a 15-day limit for certificates. Failure to register a live-in relationship was made punishable with jail or a fine.
By 19 January 2026 the state had registered 4,74,447 marriages but only 68 live-in relationships. The live-in clause was challenged in the High Court, and the state amended the Act by ordinance on 27 January 2026.
Registration that confers a benefit is taken up quickly; registration backed by punishment is avoided. A state code will need correction after it meets practice.
Tunisia became independent in March 1956 with family law based on religious jurisprudence, which allowed polygamy and divorce by the husband's declaration.
On 13 August 1956 the government of Habib Bourguiba promulgated a Code of Personal Status that abolished polygamy, required divorce through a court and made the consent of both spouses necessary for marriage. It was presented as a reinterpretation within Islamic tradition.
The code has remained in force through changes of government, and 13 August is observed in Tunisia as Women's Day.
Reform that is argued from within a community's own tradition gains a legitimacy that reform imposed from outside rarely does.
The state codes have shown that parts of the Article 44 agenda, such as compulsory registration and equal inheritance, can be delivered and are taken up by citizens. They have also shown its limits: a code that changes at the state border, exempts a large tribal population in some states and jails unregistered couples is uniform neither in reach nor in principle. The sound course is for Parliament to settle a common floor of rights first and let uniformity of form follow, with the consent of the communities it will bind.
“Several States have enacted their own Uniform Civil Codes while Parliament has not legislated. Examine whether State-level codes fulfil the mandate of Article 44. (250 words)”
“'Reform of personal laws and a Uniform Civil Code are two different routes to gender justice.' Discuss with reference to the Law Commission and the Supreme Court. (150 words)”
“Compulsory registration of live-in relationships raises questions of privacy and personal liberty. Critically examine. (150 words)”
GS2 > Indian Constitution > Directive Principles; Federal structure and Centre-State legislative relations
Polity > Directive Principles; Concurrent List; Article 254
Polity > Directive Principles and State legislation
Discuss the possible factors that inhibit India from enacting for its citizens a uniform civil code as provided for in the Directive Principles of State Policy.
What is the primary objective of a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in India?
Answer: To provide a common set of personal laws for all citizens, irrespective of religion.
Which Article of the Constitution of India mentions that "The State shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a Uniform Civil Code throughout the territory of India"?
Answer: Article 44
Which Article of the Indian Constitution mentions the "Uniform Civil Code"?
Answer: Article 44
Consider the following organizations/bodies in India: 1. The National Commission for Backward Classes 2. The National Human Rights Commission 3. The National Law Commission 4. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission How many of the above are constitutional bodies?
Answer: Only one
UPSC Mains GS2: asked directly in 2015. Directive Principles are a regular Prelims area.
One body of civil law on marriage, divorce, adoption and succession for all citizens, replacing religion-based personal laws.
Conflict between a central and a state law on the same Concurrent List subject, resolved by Article 254.
Family law that applies to a person by reason of religion or community, such as Hindu, Muslim, Christian or Parsi law.
The Governor's power under Article 200 to send a state Bill to the President, who acts under Article 201.
Several States have enacted their own Uniform Civil Codes while Parliament has not legislated. Examine whether State-level codes fulfil the mandate of Article 44, and discuss the constitutional issues they raise. (250 words)
'Reform of personal laws and a Uniform Civil Code are two different routes to gender justice.' Discuss with reference to the views of the Law Commission and the Supreme Court. (150 words)