A seven-judge Constitution Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant on 4 November 2026 answered the Arjun Flour Mills reference, pending since 1999, as infructuous because GST has replaced the old Entry 54 and the State sales tax Acts.
The bench said an additional tax or surcharge computed as a percentage of sales tax payable is an enhancement of the sales tax rate and remains a tax on the sale or purchase of goods under the then Entry 54 of the State List.
Justice K.V. Viswanathan's separate opinion held that such a levy is not a tax on the dealer's income (Entry 82, Union List) and that S. Kodar (1974) remains good law.
The dispute was over Odisha's additional tax of 10% on dealers with turnover of Rs 10 lakh to Rs 1 crore and 15% above Rs 1 crore.
Distribute legislative (including taxing) power between Parliament (List I) and States (List II); the case turned on which entry the surcharge falls under.
Earlier covered taxes on sale or purchase of goods generally. After the 101st Amendment it covers only sale of petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, aviation turbine fuel and alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
Taxes on income other than agricultural income. Dealers argued a tax on tax was really an income tax; the court said sales tax attaches to turnover, not profit.
Introduced GST (in force from 1 July 2017), substituting Entry 54 - the reason the bench called the reference academic.
Consolidated Fund of a State; the open Punjab question is whether cess proceeds could go straight to a social security fund without passing through it.
S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (five judges) upholds the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970 on dealers with turnover above Rs 10 lakh as a tax on sale of goods
Hoechst Pharmaceuticals v. State of Bihar upholds a surcharge under the Bihar Finance Act, 1981 calculated as a percentage of sales tax payable
India Cement v. State of Tamil Nadu (seven judges) treats royalty as a tax and strikes down a cess on it - later read as casting doubt on levies computed on another levy
Arjun Flour Mills (Odisha's Section 5A levy) and the Kodar question referred to a seven-judge bench
Mineral Area Development Authority v. SAIL (nine judges) holds royalty is not a tax and overrules India Cement on that point
Seven-judge bench reserves judgment; the Union calls the issue largely academic after GST
Reference answered as infructuous; Kodar held correctly decided
Legislative competence follows the nature of a tax, not how it is computed. A 10% surcharge on a 10% sales tax equals an extra 1% on turnover, so it still taxes the sale. Because dealers owe it even at a loss, it cannot be an income tax.
Simple Analogy: Raising a bus fare by 10% of the fare is still a fare, not a new tax.
Under Article 145(3), a bench of at least five judges decides substantial questions of constitutional interpretation; larger benches resolve conflicts between smaller ones
Constitutional body under Article 279A that recommends GST rates and rules; its creation took most sales taxation out of Entry 54
GS Paper II > Polity > Centre-State Relations (Seventh Schedule, taxation powers); GS III > Indirect taxes and GST
General Awareness > Polity > Seventh Schedule lists
Schedule VII of the Constitution contains:
Answer: Three legislative lists
We adopted parliamentary democracy based on the British model, but how does our model differ from that model? 1. As regards legislation, the British Parliament is supreme or sovereign but in India, the power of the Parliament to legislate is limited. 2. In India, matters related to the constitutionality of the Amendment of an Act of the Parliament are referred to the Constitution Bench by the Supreme Court. Select the correct answer using the code given below.
Answer: Both 1 and 2
The sales tax you pay while purchasing a toothpaste is a
Answer: tax imposed and collected by the State Government
A question or petition that no longer needs deciding because circumstances have changed - here, GST replacing the old law.
The test that classifies a law by its true nature, not its incidental effects or method of computation.
A levy on gross sales value, payable regardless of profit - the feature that separates sales tax from income tax.