The 2021 amendment that restored the power of States and Union Territories to prepare their own lists of socially and educationally backward classes (OBCs).
The Constitution (One Hundred and Fifth Amendment) Act, 2021 restored the power of States and Union Territories to identify and list their own socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs, commonly called OBCs). It was Parliament's answer to the Supreme Court's May 2021 Maratha reservation judgment, which had read the 102nd Amendment as leaving that power with the President alone. The Act amended Article 342A so that the President's list is the Central List, for the Centre's purposes only, and added clause (3) letting each State or UT keep its own list, which may differ from the Central List. It received the President's assent on 18 August 2021 and was deemed to have come into force on 15 August 2021.
Type: LawArticle 342A(1) amended: the President's notification now specifies SEBCs in the Central List 'for the purposes of the Central Government'.
New Article 342A(3): every State and UT may, by its own law, prepare and maintain a list of SEBCs for its own purposes; it may differ from the Central List.
An Explanation defines the Central List as the list prepared and maintained by and for the Central Government.
A proviso to Article 338B(9) means States need not consult the NCBC when preparing their own lists.
Article 366(26C) amended so that SEBCs are those deemed so under Article 342A for the Centre, or for a State or UT, as the case may be.
It did not touch the 50% ceiling on total reservation laid down in Indra Sawhney (1992), although several MPs asked for it to be lifted.
Frequency: Reservation questions appear regularly; the 102nd-105th sequence is a favourite for statement-based Prelims questions and Mains questions on federalism.
For decades, the Centre and the States each kept their own OBC lists. The 102nd Amendment (2018) inserted Article 342A, under which the President specifies SEBCs. In the Maratha reservation case, the Supreme Court struck down Maharashtra's law giving Marathas reservation as an SEBC, and the majority held that after the 102nd Amendment only the President could identify SEBCs, with States limited to making recommendations. That would have invalidated State OBC lists across the country. The review petition was dismissed on 28 June 2021, and Parliament amended the Constitution within weeks.
102nd Amendment inserts Article 342A
Supreme Court's Maratha judgment: only the President can identify SEBCs (3:2)
Review petition dismissed
127th Amendment Bill introduced in the Lok Sabha
Passed by the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha
President's assent; deemed in force from 15 August 2021
Article 342A(1)
President specifies SEBCs in the Central List for the Central Government's purposes
Article 342A(3)
States and UTs may keep their own SEBC lists by law
Article 338B(9) proviso
Consultation with NCBC not needed for State lists
Article 366(26C)
Definition of SEBCs for the Centre, a State or a UT
Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil v. CM, Maharashtra (2021)
The judgment the amendment responded to; also struck down the Maratha quota and reaffirmed the 50% ceiling
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992)
Source of the 50% ceiling, which the amendment left intact
| Aspect | 102nd Amendment, 2018 | 105th Amendment, 2021 |
|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | Constitutional status for NCBC | Restore States' power to list SEBCs |
| Bill number | 123rd Amendment Bill, 2017 | 127th Amendment Bill, 2021 |
| Article 342A | Inserted: President specifies SEBCs | Amended: President's list is the Central List; new clause (3) for State lists |
| Assent | 11 August 2018 | 18 August 2021 |
105th Amendment, 2021 = States/UTs get back the power to make their own OBC (SEBC) lists.
Bill: 127th Amendment Bill, 2021; passed 10-11 August 2021 without a vote against.
Assent 18 August 2021; deemed in force 15 August 2021.
Article 342A(3) added; President's list = Central List.
Reversed the effect of the 5 May 2021 Maratha judgment (Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil).
50% reservation ceiling left unchanged.
It restored the power of States and Union Territories to prepare their own lists of socially and educationally backward classes, by amending Article 342A and adding clause (3).
In the Maratha reservation case (5 May 2021), the Supreme Court held that after the 102nd Amendment only the President could identify SEBCs. That would have invalidated State OBC lists, so Parliament amended the Constitution.
No. The 50% ceiling from the Indra Sawhney judgment remains.
The Constitution (127th Amendment) Bill, 2021.
The amendment that made the National Commission for Backward Classes a constitutional body under Article 338B and inserted Article 342A on SEBC lists.
The Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam, which reserves one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies for women, effective after the next census and delimitation.