An electoral system that gives parties seats in proportion to their votes; India uses it, via the single transferable vote, for indirect elections.
Proportional representation (PR) is an electoral system in which seats are shared out in proportion to the votes each party or group receives, so that a party with 30% of the vote gets roughly 30% of the seats. It stands in contrast to first-past-the-post (FPTP), where the candidate with the most votes in a constituency wins and all other votes count for nothing. India's Constitution uses one form of PR — the single transferable vote (STV) — for its indirect elections: the President, the Vice-President, Rajya Sabha members and members of State Legislative Councils. Lok Sabha and State Assemblies are elected by FPTP.
Type: ProcessSeats follow vote share — PR aims to make the legislature a mirror of how people voted, so minorities and smaller parties get represented.
Needs multi-member seats — PR cannot work when only one seat is being filled; in a single-seat contest (such as the President's election) STV works out in practice as a preference-based majority vote.
Main forms: party-list PR (voters choose a party), single transferable vote (voters rank candidates) and mixed-member proportional (a constituency vote plus a party vote).
In India, PR is always by STV, and is used only for INDIRECT elections where the voters are legislators or special electorates.
Voting is by secret ballot for the President and Vice-President, but by OPEN ballot for Rajya Sabha since the Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 2003.
STV lets each voter rank candidates in order of preference, so a vote that is not needed by one candidate, or would be wasted on a losing candidate, moves to the voter's next choice.
Step 1: Each voter marks 1 against the first choice, 2 against the second, and so on. Only the first preference is compulsory for the vote to be valid.
Step 2: A quota is fixed. The usual (Droop) quota is (valid votes ÷ (seats + 1)) + 1, ignoring fractions.
Step 3: Any candidate whose first-preference votes reach the quota is elected.
Step 4: The winner's surplus votes above the quota are transferred to the next preferences marked on those ballots.
Step 5: If seats are still unfilled, the lowest-placed candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next preferences.
Step 6: Transfers and eliminations continue until every seat is filled.
Article 55(3)
President elected by PR through STV, by secret ballot; Art. 55(2) sets the value of each MLA's and MP's vote (based on the 1971 census until the first census after 2026 is published).
Article 66(1)
Vice-President elected by members of both Houses of Parliament by PR through STV, by secret ballot.
Article 80(4)
Rajya Sabha representatives of each State elected by the elected members of its Legislative Assembly by PR through STV.
Article 171(4)
Elected members of a State Legislative Council — from local authorities, graduates, teachers and the Assembly — chosen by PR through STV.
Article 81
Lok Sabha members chosen by direct election from territorial constituencies; the FPTP rule comes from the Representation of the People Act.
Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 2003
Introduced open ballot for Rajya Sabha elections (proviso to Section 59) and removed the requirement that a candidate be an elector of the State he or she represents.
| Aspect | Proportional Representation | First-Past-the-Post |
|---|---|---|
| Seats per constituency | Several (multi-member) | One (single-member) |
| Who wins | Seats shared by vote share or quota | Candidate with the most votes, even without a majority |
| Wasted votes | Few — votes transfer or count towards party share | Many — votes for losers count for nothing |
| Effect on parties | More parties, frequent coalitions | Tends to give one party a working majority |
| Voter-representative link | Weaker, especially in list systems | Strong — one MP per constituency |
| Use in India | President, Vice-President, Rajya Sabha, Legislative Councils | Lok Sabha, State Legislative Assemblies |
The Constituent Assembly debated PR for direct elections and rejected it: it feared that PR would multiply parties, make coalition governments unavoidable and destabilise a new parliamentary democracy, and judged it too complex for a largely illiterate electorate. Members such as Karimuddin and K.T. Shah argued for PR or STV. The question has returned through the Law Commission.
Constituent Assembly debates and rejects PR for direct elections; FPTP retained
70th Amendment adds elected members of the Delhi and Puducherry assemblies to the President's electoral college
Law Commission's 170th Report on electoral reforms recommends introducing list-based PR alongside FPTP by adding seats
Open ballot introduced for Rajya Sabha elections
Supreme Court upholds open ballot in Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India
Law Commission's 255th Report asks the government to examine the 170th Report's PR proposals
Election Commission of India
Conducts elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President (Article 324)
Law Commission of India
Examined PR in its 170th (1999) and 255th (2015) reports on electoral reform
Party-list PR is used in Israel and the Netherlands, which both count votes nationwide. STV is used for Ireland's Dáil, Malta's House of Representatives and the Australian Senate. Germany pioneered mixed-member proportional (MMP) representation after the Second World War, and New Zealand moved from FPTP to MMP after a 1993 referendum, holding its first MMP election on 12 October 1996. The UK, the USA and India use FPTP for their lower houses.
PR = seats in proportion to votes; FPTP = most votes in a constituency wins.
India's PR is always by single transferable vote (STV).
STV is used for: President (Art. 55), Vice-President (Art. 66), Rajya Sabha (Art. 80(4)), Legislative Councils (Art. 171(4)).
Lok Sabha and State Assemblies: FPTP.
President and Vice-President: secret ballot; Rajya Sabha: open ballot since 2003.
Droop quota = (valid votes ÷ (seats + 1)) + 1.
Law Commission 170th Report (1999) and 255th Report (2015) examined mixing PR with FPTP.
The elections of the President, the Vice-President, Rajya Sabha members and the elected members of State Legislative Councils, all by means of the single transferable vote.
The Constituent Assembly chose FPTP because PR tends to fragment the legislature into many parties and make coalition governments unavoidable, which it feared would destabilise a parliamentary system.
No. Since the Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 2003, Rajya Sabha elections use an open ballot, and the Supreme Court upheld this in Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India (2006).
PR is the broad principle that seats follow votes. STV is one method of achieving it, in which voters rank candidates and surplus or wasted votes transfer to later preferences.