On 4 October 2026, Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan said at NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad, that the right to vote is a constitutional right forming part of the basic structure, and that disenfranchising citizens is 'intrinsically arbitrary' and violates Articles 14 and 326.
He said no voter's name should be deleted without notice and a hearing — remarks made while petitions on the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls were pending in the Supreme Court.
Former CJI B.R. Gavai said judicial propriety did not permit comment on a sub judice matter; former SC judges Abhay Oka and Markandey Katju defended the judge's right to speak.
The yardstick in the debate is the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life, adopted by the Supreme Court's Full Court on 7 May 1997, whose clause 8 bars public views on matters pending or likely to arise for judicial determination.
Code of conduct for judges. Clause 8: a judge shall not enter into public debate or express views in public on political matters or on matters pending or likely to arise for judicial determination. Clause 9: a judge's judgments should speak for themselves; no media interviews. Later adopted by the Chief Justices' Conference (1999) and the High Courts; it carries no sanction of its own
Equality before law and equal protection of laws — the basis of the 'arbitrariness' test the judge applied to mass deletions
One general electoral roll for every constituency; no one is excluded from it only on grounds of religion, race, caste or sex
Elections to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies on the basis of adult suffrage; voting age cut from 21 to 18 by the 61st Amendment Act, 1988
Statutory basis for preparing and revising electoral rolls — the law under which the Election Commission runs revisions such as the SIR
A judge may discuss constitutional law in public, but should not say anything that suggests a view on a dispute that is pending or may come before a court. The test is appearance: would a fair observer think the judge has already made up their mind?
Simple Analogy: A referee can explain the rules, but should not predict the result of a match they are refereeing.
Supreme Court held the right to elect is neither a fundamental nor a common-law right but 'pure and simple, a statutory right'
Constitution Bench again treated the right to vote as statutory — the position Justice Bhuyan's 'constitutional right, part of basic structure' framing departs from
Origin of the basic structure doctrine; free and fair elections and democracy have since been treated as part of it
Hearing petitions on the SIR of electoral rolls; its Full Court adopted the 1997 Restatement
Constitutional body under Article 324 that superintends elections and electoral rolls; conducts the Special Intensive Revision
GS Paper II > Judiciary; Representation of People's Act; GS Paper IV > Probity and ethics in public institutions
Right to vote and to be elected in India is a
Answer: Constitutional Right
A matter under judicial consideration, on which public comment that may prejudice the outcome is avoided
Judges' code of conduct adopted by the Supreme Court's Full Court on 7 May 1997
Vote for every citizen aged 18 or above not otherwise disqualified — Article 326