On 9 November 2026, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla (Southern District of New York) allowed Gurpatwant Singh Pannun to serve his civil suit on NSA Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel through district courts in Delhi.
The judge relied on Article 19 of the Hague Service Convention, read with a 2009 Indian notification; India says service must go through its designated Central Authority.
Pannun must submit a service packet for approval by 30 November; an earlier attempt during PM Modi's February 2025 Washington visit was ruled invalid.
India has banned Pannun's Sikhs for Justice under UAPA and calls the suit unwarranted and unsubstantiated.
India acceded in 2006, named the Department of Legal Affairs (Ministry of Law and Justice) as its Central Authority, and objected to the Article 10 alternative channels. The judge read Article 19, which allows any other channel the destination State's own law permits, together with a 2009 Law Ministry notification letting civil courts of Convention countries send summons to Indian courts.
Governs suits against foreign states; the US State Department served the Government of India through diplomatic channels on 9 October 2026, calling it a procedural duty, not a view on the merits.
Sikhs for Justice declared an unlawful association in 2019, extended for five years from 10 July 2024; Pannun designated an individual terrorist in 2020.
India bans Sikhs for Justice under UAPA
Pannun designated an individual terrorist
SDNY issues summons in Pannun's civil suit
Attempt to serve Doval during PM Modi's Washington visit; ruled invalid in March 2025
Nikhil Gupta pleads guilty to murder-for-hire, conspiracy and money-laundering conspiracy counts in the separate criminal case
US State Department serves the Government of India under the FSIA
Judge allows service on Doval and Goel through Delhi courts
Intergovernmental body under which the 1965 Service Convention was concluded
India's Central Authority for incoming service requests under the Convention
GS Paper II > International Relations > India-US relations; GS Paper III > Internal security
The office each Hague Service Convention party designates to receive and execute foreign service requests
The principle that a state cannot be sued in another state's courts without its consent; codified in the US by the FSIA, 1976
Formal delivery of a summons and complaint so that a court can proceed against a defendant